The oral systemic health link has now become well recognized and numerous publications have discussed the importance of
the oral microbiome in the overall health of any individual. This is likely even more important in children and this influences their
future health as they mature. What is particularly interesting is that the microbiome of a child is developed prior to birth and is
related to the maternal oral microbiome. Early intervention to the mother prior to the child’s birth, with proper sleep, exercise
and dietary adjustments such as the limitation of added sugars and use of coconut oil, for example, will influence the developing
child’s microbiome. Direct influence with the polyols xylitol and erythritol to reduce pathogens, and probiotics to boost levels of
commensals would also be required. Due to the extent of oral disease, and its tremendous associated costs, urgent action is required
by all health professions.
Every species depends on adaptation to survive. Humans have
managed to survive and flourish while directly influencing the
environment of the entire planet, encompassing all other forms
of life. While there may be philosophical disagreements as to the
inadvertent harm to our natural surroundings, the human species,
homo sapiens, has been the only survivor of the hominins [1]. The
biology of this success is intertwined in the coevolution of homo
sapiens and the associated holobiome [2,3]. Chronic illnesses and
debilitations appear to be increasing, requiring reflection into the
evolutionary process, and the perturbations that have recently
occurred creating this environment of now-declining health [4].
Current research would point to the “Hygiene hypothesis”, overuse
of anti-microbials, dietary shifts and the resultant decrease in
human microbiome diversity [5,6]. The old model of looking for
an increase in pathogens is flawed. Indeed, the fault lies with the
decrease in commensals that not only compete directly with the
pathogens, but also modulate the immune response of the host
[7]. To improve the health of children, we must first improve the
microbiome of the mother. The maternal microbiome sets the stage
for the child’s microbiome [8,9].
Pre-natal intervention has been studied with positive results
reported by the supplementation of the mother with probiotics
or polyols [10,11]. Published studies using xylitol that involve
the nursing mother and child have demonstrated the decrease in
the maternal transmission of mutans streptococci [12]. Certainly,
intervention may be desired even earlier, preferably before
pregnancy because it is also reported that antecedent use of
antibiotics by the mother will influence the maternal microbiome
[13]. The placental microbiome is most closely related to the
maternal oral microbiome [14]. The presence of commensal
bacteria in the placenta and developing fetus is essential to fetal
immunological maturation [15]. The oral health of the expectant
mother should then be considered primarily important to the oral
systemic health of the fetus and later, the child. In addition, the
placental microbiome appears to be developed quite early in the
pregnancy, by maternal imprinting [14]. This maternal imprinting
involves the transportation of viable commensals via circulating
monocytes, properly creating a fetal microbiome to program the
developing child [16]. Animal studies have demonstrated the
transmission of maternal breast commensals into the amniotic
fluid [17]. All this depends upon the mother actually having
a healthy microbiome [18]. The maternal microbiome can be
influenced in numerous ways including diet, exercise and probiotic
supplementation [19-22]. Limiting added dietary sugar and the
regular addition of polyols can help decrease the prevalence of
pathogens before they are passed on to the child [12,23-25]. In the
case of Early Childhood Caries, the reduction of maternal Candida
albicans will reduce the biofilm formation by Streptococcus mutans
potentially reducing the incidence of dental caries [26,27]. Some
Lactobacilli, all probiotics such as Lactobacilli rhamnosus, have
been demonstrated to inhibit Candida albicans [28-30]. Other
supplements, such as N-acetyl cysteine, also have a reducing effect
on Candida albicans levels [31-32]. Coconut oil in the form of
Medium Chain Triglycerides (MCT) supplements has also been used
to reduce levels of Candida albicans and is reportedly as effective as
ketoconazole [33-35]. But it has also been reported that coconut
oil has more beneficial components than just MCT, giving pause
as to why whole coconut oil isn’t utilized more [36]. Regardless,
MCT may increase exercise endurance and encourage weight loss
[37]. In addition, another natural product, propolis has also been
demonstrated to inhibit Candida albicans and other oral pathogens
[38-40]. If the expectant mother increases exposure to coconut
oil or N-AC, the inhibitory effects may be beneficial in preventing
the onset of ECC or, possibly Candida albicans systemic disease if
prematurely born [41].
Vitamin K2 has also been reported as being very beneficial as
an anti-caries agent and for activation of proper bone and dentin
formation in concert with vitamins A and D [42]. This research isn’t
new, but recently furthered explored and reported [43]. Insufficient
levels of Vitamin D have been linked to S-ECC in a number of studies
[44-47]. With increased publications of the beneficial properties of
these supplements, it is surprising that the dental profession has
not enthusiastically adopted a more fully energetic policy on their
role in preventing ECC, especially considering the lack of important
micronutrients in the typical American fast food diet [48]. The
method of birth has been greatly researched demonstrating that
C-section results in an increase in childhood allergies and asthma
[49]. The research implicates the lack of exposure to the bacteria
of the birth canal and anus as being causative with the neonate’s
microbiome lacking maternal commensals [50]. After birth, either
by vaginal delivery or C-section, breast feeding provides the infant
with Human Milk Oligosaccharides which are much more than
just food for bacteria as originally proposed for the child [51]. The
HMOs also are antiadhesive antimicrobials that serve as soluble
decoy receptors, preventing pathogens attachment to the infant’s
mucosal surfaces and thereby lowering the risk for viral, bacterial
and protozoan parasite infections [52,53].
HMO’s also reportedly modulate epithelial and immune cell
responses, reducing excessive mucosal leukocyte infiltration and
activation, lowering the risk for necrotizing enterocolitis and
providing the infant with sialic acid, a potentially essential nutrient
for brain development and cognition [54,55]. Formula does not
have the same protective properties that breastmilk does and sadly,
many pediatric dentists criticize breast feeding as being cariogenic,
even though published research links the associated dental caries
to additional carbohydrate intake and night feeding [56,57]. The
benefits of breast feeding have been well documented, and the
need to adjust the preventive dentistry protocol to accommodate
breast feeding should be evident [58]. Although the World Health
Organization recommends two years, mothers probably should
breast feed their infants for a least a year, the time interval reported
to be the found in early hominins, Australopithecus africanus
[59]. Another benefit from breast feeding, besides developing
the microbiome and immune modulation, could be regulation
of metals, especially zinc and copper, protecting the neurological
development of the infant [60-62].
Streptococcus mutans has long been considered the key
pathogen for the development of dental caries, the most prevalent
chronic disease of humans [63-65]. Efforts to reduce the levels
of Streptococcus mutans in infants and children with xylitol and
preventing dental caries have been successful, raising the question
as to why this is not standard dental practice. 66-67 However, other
bacterial and fungal organisms have now been closely identified
with the development of dental caries [68]. Scardovia wiggsiae
is a Bacillus bacterium found extensively associated with Severe-
Early Childhood Caries [69]. Scardovia wiggsiae and Slackia exigua
have been reported to be involved in the early caries development
[70]. Candida albicans, a fungal organism, helps with the biofilm
production by increasing the extracellular polysaccharide matrix
which protects Streptococcus mutans from anti-microbials
and commensals such as Streptococcus oralis [71]. Lactobacilli
inhibit the colonization of Candida albicans, hence decreasing
the polysaccharide matrix, exposing the Streptococcus mutans to
the bactericins or hydrogen peroxide of its natural competitors,
other Streptococcus species [72]. Streptococcus oralis produces
hydrogen peroxide that inhibits the anaerobic Streptococcus
mutans growth [73,74]. Indeed, Probiora probiotic, a commercially
available probiotic product, contains Streptococcus oralis, uberis
and rattus, and claims to inhibit several key dental pathogens [75-
77]. Probiotics have been reported to be an important adjunct in
preventive dental care [78-80].
Erythritol and xylitol are polyols that have been extensively
researched and demonstrated to have notable anti-cariogenic and
anti-periodontal disease properties [81,82]. Polyols (particularly
the non-hexitol alditols or sugar alcohols erythritol and xylitol)
have been found effective in inhibiting the transition to and
maturation of biofilms from planktonic cells [83]. Xylitol clearly
inhibited the formation of mixed species biofilms, which included
Porphyromonas gingivalis in vitro [84]. Erythritol suppressed the
maturation of gingivitis biofilms and contributed to a healthier
oral ecosystem [85]. Porphyromonas gingivalis takes advantage
of early colonizers (Streptococci and Candida) to provide
attachment and protection within the biofilm matrix. Polyols can
reduce extracellular polysaccharide production and interfere
with biofilm matrix elaboration, thereby reducing adherence and
biofilm development [86-88]. Streptococci and Candida utilize
common dietary sugars sucrose and D-glucose for preferred
energy sources, as well as for polysaccharide production. Higher
glucose concentrations stimulate Candida growth. Compared with
common D-sugars, xylitol induced the lowest adhesion and biofilm
formation on either Streptococcus mutans or Candida albicans
[89]. In addition, xylitol has been demonstrated to decrease the
levels of cariogenic bacteria while having little effect on beneficial
bacteria [90]. The discovery of bacteriophages specific for certain
strains of Streptococcus mutans also show great promise in the
management of pediatric oral health [91]. With the costs of dental
disease rapidly escalating, now (2010) estimated at 442 billion US
dollars, all effective measures to prevent oral disease should be
urgently started in the pediatric population [92].
The Airway evaluation of the infant/toddler is of paramount
importance during the first Age One examination [31]. Airway
issues in children have been linked to future obesity, diabetes
and behavioral issues [94,95]. Mouth breathing increases the oral
microbiome pathogenic potential, as the incoming air will reduce
the protective nature of the saliva [96]. Studies have demonstrated
the correlation between oral disease and airway pathology [97,98].
Sleep Disturbed Breathing in children has been extensively reviewed
in the literature, describing an ever-increasing pathologic chain of
events [99,100]. Amongst the deleterious effects of mouth breathing
are lower and mid-facial adaptations, orthodontic malocclusions,
potential speech issues, esthetic concerns, sleep disturbed bruxism,
and future temporomandibular joint dysfunctions [101-104]. The
key to the future health of children is effective preventive care. What
becomes a serious morbidity in adulthood started in childhood.
Now more than ever, pediatric health care providers need to
emphasize the connection between the oral health of children and
their systemic health, with all the future ramifications now clearly
reported in the scientific literature. The importance of the oral
microbiome, its role as a “gateway” microbiome, and the systemic
connection need to be more fully explained to patients, parents and
all health care professionals.
Interestingly, the oral health care of the child starts before birth,
requiring the participation of all involved in pre-natal care. It is
now obvious that what is most important may be the microbiome,
and how it is affected by the environment, diet, sleep, exercise,
antibiotics, polyols and probiotics. The microbiome then modulates
the immune system, allergies, resistance to pathogens, autoimmune
responses, and ultimately patient health and longevity. At
last, there seems to be great interest in the importance of pediatric
and general oral health due to the crisis that poor oral health is
bringing upon us [105]. We should be concerned that research
studies from several countries have all reported neurotoxicity
effects from relatively low levels of fluoride in children [106-
111]. Our over reliance on fluoride to create fluorapatite to inhibit
decay seems inadequate at best. Perhaps this means that the time
has come to treat a bacterial disease, as a bacterial disease. After
all, dental caries and periodontal disease, and to a great extent
downstream comorbidity including atherosclerosis, diabetes,
strokes, inflammatory Alzheimer’s, diabetes, and many systemic
illnesses, can be traced back to a “dysbiosis” started in infancy.
Brown T, Creed S, Alexander S, Barnard K, Bridges N, et al. (2012) Vitamin D deficiency in children with dental caries -a prevalence study. Arch Dis Child 97(1): 1-186.
Elde SJ, Haytowitz DB, Howe J, Peterson JW, Booth, SL (2006) Vitamin k contents of meat, dairy, and fast food in the US Diet. Journal of agricultural and food chemistry 54(2): 463-467
Marcobal, A, Sonnenburg JL (2012) Human milk oligosaccharide consumption by intestinal microbiota. Clinical microbiology and infection: the official publication of the European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases 4(4): 12-15.
Hillman JD, Socransky SS (1989) The theory and application of bacterial interference to oral diseases. In New Biotechnology in Oral Research. ed. Myers HM (Basel: S Karger) 1-17.