ISSN: 2641-1768
Honglei Yin*, Qianqian Xin, Xiang Xue and Enze Li
Received: February 18, 2020; Published: February 25, 2020
Corresponding author: Honglei Yin, Department of Psychiatry, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou, China
DOI: 10.32474/SJPBS.2020.03.000168
Cognitive distortion has been proposed as one of the endophenotypes of suicidal behavior, and a therapeutic target in the suicidal patient approach. This article provides a systematic review of the existing literature testing relations between cognitive distortion and suicidality, across various diagnostic and demographic populations, using different kinds of neurocognitive tasks, together with imaging or electrophysiological test to measure the alteration of brain regions during the neurocognitive tasks. Cognitive distortion is an important factor in the generation process of suicidal behavior and should be a promising target in the prevention and treatment of suicidal behavior. Future study needs to pay attention to the consistency of samples including psychiatric diagnosis, time period between the last suicide attempt (SA) and investigation day, and the mechanisms how the genes related with suicidal behavior together with environmental factors alter the risk of suicidal behavior through their influence on cognitive distortion..
Keywords: Cognitive distortion; Suicide attempt; Suicide ideation; Imaging test
Suicide is an important global public problem, with an
estimated 800,000 people die by suicide each year worldwide
and is the fifth most common cause of death and the second most
common external cause of death in China [1]. Usually, suicidal
behavior can be classified as suicide idea (SI), SA and suicide death.
Non-fatal suicidal behaviors are more common than suicides.
Although many researches discovered the gene-environmental
and psychosocial characters for suicide [2-4], the risk factors of
suicidal behavior remained unknown. Now, there has been great
improvement in the research of the cognitive mechanisms of
suicidal behavior. Cognitive distortion is not only viewed as one
of the candidates endophenotypes of suicidal behavior, but also
a therapeutic target in the suicidal patient approach [5]. Suicidal
individuals are more likely than non-suicidal individuals to
experience cognitive distortions, defined as errors in both cognitive
processing and content that result in maladaptive or unhelpful
interpretations of incoming stimuli [6]. different types of primary
cognitive alterations are related to suicidal behavior, especially
those resulting from changes in front striatal circuits [7]. Among
such cognitive mechanisms can be highlighted the executive
function impairment and attentional bias.
Executive function relies heavily upon three distinguishable
abilities or “functions”:
1) Avoiding/suppressing habitual or “pre-potent” responses
(i.e., inhibition).
2) Switching between tasks or mental “sets” (i.e., shifting)
and.
3) Monitoring/controlling the contents of working memory
(i.e., updating) [8].
Almost all the aspects of executive function are impaired in
suicidality, including poor decision making and planning, response
Inhibition, verbal fluency, and so on [9]. In addition to these deficits,
suicide attempters also showed a higher sensitivity to interference
[10]. In the classical version of the Stroop task, the suicidal patients
took significantly longer to name the colors of suicide-related words
compared with other words, which means that the attentional bias
exhibited by suicidal patients was highly specific [11]. Nowadays,
using the modified Stroop task, together with various imaging
detection methods, researchers have got further understanding of
attentional bias in suicidal behavior. There is a need to synthesize
evidence from cumulating literature on cognitive deficits in suicide
attempters in order to get a comprehensive impression of the
cognition distortion associated with a history of suicidal act. In
the current paper, we systematically reviewed the literature on the
cognitive distortion of suicidal behavior.
Many studies found that suicide attempters tended to make
more risky decisions as assessed with the decision-making tasks
including the Game of Dice Task (GDT), the Iowa Gambling Task
(IGT) and the Cambridge Gambling Task (CGT) than control group
[12-16]. A meta-analysis of 10 studies using IGT to measure
decision making in patients with a history of suicidal acts in bipolar
and unipolar disorder, confirmed significantly impaired decisionmaking
with a moderate effect-size in bipolar disorder suicide
attempters compared to unipolar and bipolar non-attempters
[17]. Some studies investigated the influence of genes relevant to
suicidal behavior on decision-making. found that patients with
a personal history of attempted suicide carrying the specific
polymorphisms of four serotonergic genes significantly improved
their performance during IGT, suggesting a genetic modulation of
the learning process required for advantageous decision-making
[18], found that, suicide attempters with a history of sexual abuse
had significantly lower IGT scores than non-sexually abused
individuals, and Polymorphisms within corticotrophin releasing
hormone receptor 1(CRHR1) and CRHR2 genes interacted with
both childhood sexual abuse and emotional neglect to influence IGT
performance [19].
There were some studies focusing on specific population
groups. One study compared performance on CGT in four groups
of older adults and found that the suicide attempters exhibited
poorer ability to choose the likely outcome which suggesting that
older suicide attempters seem to neglect outcome probability and
make poor choices [20]. Most studies investigating decision making
abilities in suicide attempters had used one single task and included
patients with a lifetime history of suicide attempts, therefore
yielded conflicting results. Some studies focused on recent suicide
attempt (within 72h or the last 6 months) found that, Investigation
of state-dependent neuropsychological characteristics of suicidal
behaviour might be essential for detecting acute suicidal crisis
[21,22]. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) was used
to measure the brain activation following the decision making tasks
in suicide attempters, one study supported a significant role for
deficient risk processing, and ventral and dorsal prefrontal cortex
functioning in the suicidal diathesis [23], while another suggested
that a history of suicidal attempt in schizophrenia is associated
with blunted brain reward activity during emotional decisionmaking
[24].
In 2009, a study measured two complementary aspects of response inhibition: attention-based and reward-based, found that faster reaction time to a commission error on the Immediate Memory Task (IMT) was associated with history of SA [25]. Some studies used fMRI to measure brain activation during the Go/No- Go response inhibition task, and conflict results were found. One study found decreased activity in the right anterior cingulate gyrus in SA [26], while another found no difference in brain activation [27]. Investigated the Continuous Performance Task (CPT) of 228 girls with and without attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), found that Childhood response inhibition could predict young-adult SI, SA, and non-suicidal self-injury [28]. Another study also found that depressed attempters were clearly distinguished by a deficit in response inhibition (Go/No-go commission errors) [29]. A recent study found that the neurocognitive assessment of response inhibition and memory recognition shows sensitivity to the recency of a SA which suggested that phasic neurocognitive deficits may serve as objective markers of short-term suicide risk [30].
A meta-analysis in 2015 examined the association between memory deficits and vulnerability to suicidal acts in 24 studies (including 2,595 participants), four different types of memory (i.e., working memory, short- and long-term memory, and autobiographical memory) were assessed, and found that long-term memory and working memory were both more impaired in suicide attempters [31]. Several studies used MRI or fMRI to examine the structure or the functional changes in brain regions following the working memory task in patients with SI, the results were not consistent may be because of different diagnosis. One study showed that depressed patients with high suicidal ideation retained fewer negative schematic facial stimuli in white matter (WM) [32], while another study found that first-episode schizophrenia with suicidal ideation showed preserved WM integrity, and had less cognitive deficit in working memory and verbal comprehension possibly because of greater insight [33].
It is used single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) following a verbal fluency paradigm to evaluate the perfusion of different brain regions, they found differences in regional cortical activation between the letter fluency and category fluency tasks and a blunted increase in prefrontal blood perfusion in attempted suicide patients [34]. Richard-Devantoy then reviewed seven neuropsychological tests in a total of 25 studies (2323 participants) to identify neuropsychological tests of vulnerability to suicidal acts in patients with mood disorders, and found that IGT, category verbal fluency and Stroop performance were lower in suicide attempters than in patient controls and healthy controls[5]. Several studies used near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS), an optical neuroimaging technology that used near-infrared light to track changes in the concentration of oxygenated and deoxygenated hemoglobin (Hb), to measure the activation of brain regions during the verbal fluency task (VFT), and found reduced activation during VFT in several brain regions including frontal, temporal and left precentral gyrus [35,36]. Two studies also found prefrontal asymmetry [37] or smaller hemodynamic changes in the frontal regions [38] during VFT in depressed patients with SI.
A meta-analysis of four studies, including 233 suicide attempters and 768 patient controls, showed a significant but small attentional bias toward suicide-related words in suicide attempters compared to patient controls [10]. After that time, some research used imaging or electrophysiological test together with psychological task to better understand the attentional bias in suicidal behavior. One study used Electroencephalographic (EEG) to record the frontal area activity during the standard and emotional Stroop tasks, found that response times to the word “suicide” were significantly slower for the high-risk group, and in the emotional Stroop task the high-risk group showed reduced activity in leftward frontal areas, suggesting limitations in the ability to regulate emotional processing via the left frontal regions [39]. Another study used the P300 component of event-related potentials (ERPs) during the spatial cueing task found that patients with low rates of suicidal behavior showed difficulty in disengaging attention from suicide-relevant stimuli [40]. Found that children with a history of SI exhibited significantly greater gaze duration toward fearful faces [41]. Investigated the emotional Stroop task (EST) of 820 college students and found that past suicide attempters were slower in responding to the word “suicide”, and female past attempters showed more delayed response when their most recent attempt was made in the past 12 months [42]. Furthermore, recent research efforts are directed to assess the possible use of attention bias as a therapeutic target in patients presenting suicide behavior [43].
According to the overview of neurocognitive factors related to suicidal behavior, a conclusion can be yielded that cognitive distortion is an important factor in the generation process of suicidal behavior and should be a promising target in the prevention and treatment of suicidal behavior. Future research needs to pay attention to the following issues: consistency of samples including psychiatric diagnosis, time period between the last SA and investigation day and so on. Future research can focus on the mechanisms of the cognitive distortion in suicidal behavior and use the neuropsychological task to select the population with high risk of suicidal behavior. The heritability of suicide is well established. Transmission of risk appears to follow traits more than disorders like depression, hence future research can focus on the mechanisms how the genes related with suicidal behavior together with environmental factors, e.g. childhood abuse, alter the risk of suicidal behavior through their influence on cognitive distortion.
This research was funded by National Natural Science Foundation of China(NSFC) (Grant number: 81801351, PI: Honglei Yin), Guangdong Natural Science Foundation (GDNSF) (Grant number: 2017A030310530, PI: Honglei Yin).
Bio chemistry
University of Texas Medical Branch, USADepartment of Criminal Justice
Liberty University, USADepartment of Psychiatry
University of Kentucky, USADepartment of Medicine
Gally International Biomedical Research & Consulting LLC, USADepartment of Urbanisation and Agricultural
Montreal university, USAOral & Maxillofacial Pathology
New York University, USAGastroenterology and Hepatology
University of Alabama, UKDepartment of Medicine
Universities of Bradford, UKOncology
Circulogene Theranostics, EnglandRadiation Chemistry
National University of Mexico, USAAnalytical Chemistry
Wentworth Institute of Technology, USAMinimally Invasive Surgery
Mercer University school of Medicine, USAPediatric Dentistry
University of Athens , GreeceThe annual scholar awards from Lupine Publishers honor a selected number Read More...