Strength Improvement and Interface Characteristic of Dissimilar Metal Joints for TC₄ Ti Alloy to Nitinol NiTi alloy Volume 3 - Issue 1

Yan Zhang¹*, DeShui Yu¹, JianPing Zhou¹, DaQian Sun² and Hong Mei Li²

• ¹Xinjiang University, School of Mechanical Engineering, Wulumuqi 830000, China
• ²Jilin University, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Changchun 130022, China

Received: May 15, 2020;   Published: May 26, 2020

*Corresponding author: Yan Zhang, Xinjiang University, School of Mechanical Engineering, Wulumuqi 830000, China

DOI: 10.32474/MAMS.2020.03.000152

Abstract PDF

Abstract

Laser welding of TC₄ Ti alloy to NiTi alloy has been applied using pure Cu as an interlayer. Mechanical properties of the joints were evaluated by tensile tests. Based on avoiding the formation of Ti-Ni intermetallics in the joint, three welding processes for Ti alloy-NiTi alloy joint were introduced. The joint was formed while the laser was acted on the Cu interlayer. Experimental results showed that Cu interlayer was helping to decrease the Ti-Ni intermetallics by forming Ti-Cu phases in the weld. The average tensile strength of the joint was 216 MPa.

Keywords: Ti alloy; NiTi alloy; Cu interlayer; Laser welding; Microstructure; Tensile strength

Introduction

TiNi alloy has shape memory and pseudo-elastic properties, excellent corrosion resistance and good biocompatibility, it provides promising solutions to solve the problems in various applications such as aerospace, atomic energy, microelectronics, and medical equipment [1,2]. As we all know, the successful application of any advanced material depends not only on its original properties, but also on its development [3]. People are more and more interested in the combination of TiNi alloy and other materials, especially for the development of devices with different mechanical properties and corrosion resistance. Ti alloy has excellent comprehensive properties, such as high specific strength, high specific modulus, hardness, corrosion resistance and high damage resistance [4,5]. It is widely used in aerospace, marine industry, biomedical engineering, and military industry. The composite materials of TiNi alloy and Ti alloy can not only meet the requirements of heat conduction, conductivity, and corrosion resistance, but also meet the requirements of high strength but light weight [6]. Therefore, it will be widely used in aerospace, instrumentation, electronics, chemical industry, and other fields. Compared with single material property, this material can use the performance and cost advantages of each material to select the best material for each structural component [7]. However, the weldability of dissimilar materials also limits the wide application of these alloys. This leads to the formation of brittle-like intermetallic compounds (IMCs) in the weld zone. For example, Ti₂Ni, NiTi, Ni₃Ti [8]. The formation of Ti-Ni IMCs in the weld makes the weld brittle, and the mismatch of the thermal expansion coefficient of the two materials, it will lead to the formation of transverse cracks in the weld and the deterioration of mechanical properties [9-11]. In fact, TiNi alloy-Ti alloy joint is one of the most direct and effective methods to increase the use of TiNi alloy, Ti alloy and other lightweight materials in the field of aerospace and engineering manufacturing and to use structural lightweight design to achieve structural optimization, energy saving, environmental protection and safety [12]. Therefore, the effective connection between TiNi alloy and Ti alloy becomes an urgent problem.

At present, the most commonly used method is to insert an intermediate layer to improve the microstructure of the joint, which can improve the mechanical stability between TiNi alloy and Ti alloy and lead to the formation of other phases except for Ti-Ni IMCs [13]. This is because the addition of intermediate layer can reduce the fusion ratio of TiNi alloy and Ti alloy in the joint. This effect reduces the content of Ti and Ni in the weld metal, thus reducing the probability of the formation of Ti-Ni IMCs in the weld metal [14,15]. Elements such as niobium, zirconium, molybdenum, tantalum, and vanadium are recommended interlayers for dissimilar welding of Ti-based alloys, since they do not react with titanium [16]. However, due to the high price and unavailability of these elements, Ag, Cu and Ni are usually used as the interlayer for the welding of these two materials, among which Cu is the most widely used interlayer in the field of dissimilar materials welding [17]. These elements will react with Ti and may form new IMCs, but in a case that the hardness of the new phases are less than that of the primary intermetallic phases formed between base metals elements (Ti-Ni IMCs in here), so it is reasonable to use these metals as the interlayer. Compared with TiNi alloy and Ti alloy, Cu has higher ductility and lower melting point, so it can reduce the influence of thermal stress mismatch caused by solidification of welding pool during welding [18]. In addition, copper is much cheaper than Zr, Ta, Mo, Ni, V and other elements, and is easy to obtain. On the other hand, according to the research of Bricknell et al. [19] on ternary shape memory alloys of Ti-Cu-Ni, nickel atoms can be substituted with copper atoms in lattice structure of NiTi. This substitution leads to the formation of Ti (Ni, Cu) ternary shape alloy at different transition temperatures. Therefore, Cu has a good compatibility with NiTi.

Experimental Procedure

Materials

The base materials used in this experiment were TC4 Ti alloy and TiNi alloy. There are large differences in thermal conductivity and linear expansion coefficient between the two base materials, which would lead to large temperature gradient and thermal stress in the joint during welding process. The base materials were machined into 50 mm×40 mm×1 mm plate, and then cleaned with acetone before welding. 0.3 mm thick Cu sheet (99.99 at. %) were adopted as interlayer and placed on the contact surface of the base material fixed in fixture.

Welding Method

CW laser was used with average power of 1.20 kW, wavelength of 1080 nm and beam spot diameter of 0.1 mm. Schematic diagram of the welding process is shown in (Figure 1). Schematic diagram of the welding process is shown in (Figure 1), where a good fitup between the TC4-Cu-NiTi was required to prevent gaps and ensure adequate heat transfer to form a joint. Laser welding for joint. During welding, laser beams were focused on the centrelines of the Cu interlayer (Figure 1). According to the thickness of the Cu interlayer to adjust welding parameters. At the same time can adjust parameters to change the fusion ratio of the base material. Laser offset for weld of joint was defined as 0 mm. The welding process parameters were: laser beam power of 396W, defocusing distance of +5 mm, welding speed of 650mm/min. Argon gas with the purity of 99.99% was applied as a shielding gas with total flow of 20L/min at top of the joint. Supplementary gas protection device covering the melted zone has been used to minimize the risk of oxidation.

Characterization Methods

The cross sections of joints were polished and etched in the reagent with 2ml concentrated HNO3 and 6 ml concentrated HF. The microstructure of joints was studied by optical microscopy (Scope Axio ZEISS), scanning electron microscope SEM (S-3400) with fast energy dispersion spectrum EDS analyzer, and selected area XRD (X’Pert3 Powder) analysis. Vickers microhardness tests for the weld carried out with a 10s load time and a 200g load. Tensile strength of the joints was measured by using universal testing machine (MTS Insight 10 kN) with cross head speed of 2mm/min.

Results and Discussion

Characterization of Joint

According to the previous research results, the microstructure, and mechanical properties of NiTi alloy/Ti alloy joint can be improved by adding appropriate interlayer materials, but the formation of brittle and hard Ti-Ni intermetallic compounds in the weld cannot be avoided. To further improve the mechanical properties of NiTi alloy/Ti alloy joint, the design idea of laser welding of NiTi alloy and Ti alloy assisted by metal transition layer is proposed in this paper. The purpose is to avoid the metallurgical reaction between Ti and Ni and improve the microstructure and mechanical properties of NiTi alloy/Ti alloy joint.

Macro-Characteristics

The optical microscopy image of the cross section of the joint is shown in (Figure 2a). The joint can fall into three parts: the fusion weld formed at the Ti alloy side, unmelted Ti alloy and the diffusion weld formed at the TiNi-Ti alloy interface. The fusion weld did not form Ti-Fe intermetallics due to the presence of unmelted Ti alloy. The average width of fusion weld, unmelted Ti alloy and diffusion weld was 1.8 mm, 0.35 mm and 0.17 mm, respectively. Because the microstructure of the fusion weld is quite different from that of the diffusion weld, the diffusion weld becomes black after corrosion. (Figure 2b) presents the optical image before corrosion of the diffusion weld. It does not present such defects as pores and macro-cracks. The unmelted part of Ti alloy acted as a heat sink absorbing a significant amount of energy from the welding pool and transferring it to the TiNi alloy side [20]. Hence, the filler metal of TiNi-Ti alloy interface had a high temperature during welding although it was not subjected to laser radiation. The temperature was high enough to promote atomic interdiffusion. This meets the temperature requirement for diffusion welding. Moreover, the local heating of the Ti alloy side caused uneven volume expansion and thermal stress was produced, which helped to obtain an intimate contact between the TiNi alloy, Cu-based fillers and Ti alloy surface. The high temperature and the intimate contact at the TiNi-Ti alloy interface provided favourable conditions for atomic (Cu, Zn, Ti, Ni) interdiffusion. Therefore, a diffusion weld was formed originated from atomic (Cu, Zn, Ti, Ni) interdiffusion at the Ti alloy-filler metal and filler metal-TiNi alloy interface. Additionally, the unmelted Ti alloy was beneficial to relieve and accommodate the thermal stress in the joint, which could help to improve the mechanical properties of the joints.

Microstructure Analysis

The optical image of the fusion weld is shown in (Figure 3a), and no defects were observed in it. SEM image of the fusion weld is shown in (Figure 3b). The fusion weld mainly consists of acicular structure. The optical image of the diffusion weld at NiTi-Ti alloy interface is shown in (Figure 3c). It can be observed that, the diffusion weld contained three zones marked as Ⅰ, Ⅱ and Ⅲ sorted by their morphologies and colours. (Figures 3d, 3e and 3f)correspond to the three zones in (Figure 3c), respectively. The compositions of each zone (denoted by letter A-C in (Figure 3)) were studied using SEM-EDS. EDS analysis was applied to these zones to measure the compositions of the reaction products and the results are listed in Table 1. Based on the previous analysis, the microstructure of the diffusion weld was mainly composed of Cu-based fillers. The chemical composition of zone Ⅰ was consistent with the Cu-based fillers. Based on the EDS analyses results and Cu-Zn phase diagram, the main microstructure of zone Ⅰ was defined as β-CuZn phase. When the laser beam was focused near the Ti alloy-filler metal interface, the element diffusion occurs immediately between the base materials and filler metal and causes its component to deviate from the original component. The interdiffusion of Cu, Zn, Ti and Ni elements occurred at diffusion welding interface (Ti alloy-filler metal and filler metal-NiTi alloy). At this moment, the dissolution of Ti and Ni into the filler metal occurred under the high concentration gradient, which formed solid-phase reaction layer, and this reaction layer exists only in the smaller region of the NiTi-Ti alloy interface. As shown in, zone Ⅱ and zone Ⅲ were reaction layers formed by element diffusion. Based on Ti-Cu-Ni phase diagram, the microstructure of zone Ⅱ was defined as TiCu₂+NiZn. Based on Cu-Ti-Zn phase diagram, the microstructure of zone Ⅲ was defined as Ti₃Cu₄+Ti₂Zn₃. Therefore, the main microstructures of diffusion weld were TiCu₂+NiZn, β-CuZn and Ti₃Cu₄+Ti₂Zn₃.

Tensile Tests and Fracture Analysis

The maximum tensile strength of the joint was about 256 MPa (Figure 5a). The joint fractured in Ti alloy side of the diffusion weld during tensile tests (Figures 5b, 5c)shows fracture surface of the joint exhibiting typical brittle characteristics. Moreover, as shown in (Figure 5d), XRD analyses of fracture surface detected Ti₃Cu₄ and Ti₂Zn₃ phases. This confirmed the presence of Ti-Cu and Ti-Zn intermetallics at fracture surfaces. It should be noted that there was no Ti-Ni intermetallics in the brazed weld. Reaction layer at Ti alloy side in diffusion weld became the weak zone of the joint, which led to the failure in the tensile test.Based on the above results, the formation of Ti-Ni intermetallic compounds is avoided due to the presence of unmelted Ti alloy in the joint. Only a small amount of Ti-Cu intermetallic compounds is formed in the reaction layer at the NiTi-Ti alloy interface. Due to the rapid heating and cooling speed of laser welding, the holding time at high temperature is short, and it is easy to form a narrow reaction zone at the NiTi-Ti alloy interface. In addition, higher cooling rate inhibited the growth of dendrite structure in the reaction zone. Therefore, it is easy to obtain fine microstructure in the reaction zone, which is conducive to reducing the brittleness of the reaction layer. The results show that the formation of narrow reaction layer and fine metallurgical structure at the interface is one of the main reasons to improve the joint strength.

Conclusion

The possibility of welding processes for connect TC₄ Ti alloy to NiTi alloy with Cu-base filler metal was studied. The main conclusions are presented below. without filler metal, For joint with a laser beam offset of 1.2 mm for Ti alloy, the unmelted Ti alloy was selected as an barrier to avoid mixing of the NiTi alloy and Ti alloy which eliminated the formation of brittle Ti-Ni intermetallic in the joint . A diffusion weld was formed at the NiTi alloy-Ti alloy interface with the main microstructure of TiCu²⁺NiZn, β-CuZn and Ti₃Cu₄+Ti₂Zn₃. A great amount of atomic diffusion occurs at the NiTi-Ti alloy interface during welding, and the thickness of diffusion weld can reach hundreds of micrometres. The tensile resistance of the joint was determined by diffusion weld. The maximum tensile strength of joint was 256 MPa.

References

1. Yang DZ (2000) Shape memory alloy and smart hybrid composites-advanced materials for the 21^st Mater Des 21: 503-505.
2. Duerig T, Pelton A, Stöckel D (1999) An overview of nitinol medical applications. Mater Sci Eng A 273-275: 149-160.
3. Brook GB (1983) Applications of titanium-nickel shape memory alloys. Mater Des 4(4): 835-840.
4. Gao M, Mei SW, Wang ZM, Li XY, Zeng XY (2012) Characterization of laser welded dissimilar Ti/steel joint using Mg interlayer, Sci. Technol. Weld. Join 17: 269-276.
5. Gao M, Wang ZM, Li XY, Zeng XY (2011) Laser keyhole welding of dissimilar Ti-6Al-4V titanium alloy to AZ31B magnesium alloy, Metall. Mater. Trans. A 43A: 163-172.
6. ShojaeiZoeram A, Akbari Mousavi SAA (2014) Laser welding of Ti-6Al-4V to Nitinol. Materials and Design 61: 185-190.
7. Donachie Jr Matthew J (1989) Titanium a technical guide. Metals Park, OH: ASM International.
8. Squillace A, Prisco U, Ciliberto S, Astarita A (2012) Effect of welding parameters on morphology and mechanical properties of Ti-6Al-4V laser beam welded butt joints. J Mater Process Technol 212: 427-436.
9. Wang SH, Wei MD, Tsay LW (2003) Tensile properties of LBW welds in Ti-6Al-4V alloy at evaluated temperatures below 450 C. Mater Lett 57: 1815-1823.
10. Saburi T, Nenno S, Fukuda T (1986) Crystal structure and morphology of the meta stable X phase in shape memory Ti-Ni alloys. J Less-Common Met 125: 157-166.
11. ASM Handbook (1992) ASM specialty handbook. Alloys phase diagrams, vol 3 Metals Park, OH: ASM International 327.
12. Casalino G, Curcio F, Memola F, Minutolo C (2005) Investigation on Ti6Al4V laser welding using statistical and Taguchi approaches. J Mater Process Technol 167: 422-428.
13. Choubey A, Basu B, Balasubramaniam R (2005) Electrochemical behavior of Ti-based alloys in simulated human body fluid environment. Trends BiomaterArtif Organs 18: 64-72.
14. Yan Zhang, Yankun Chen, Jianping Zhou (2020) Experimental and numerical study on microstructure and mechanical properties for laser welding-brazing of TC₄ Titanium alloy and 304 stainless steel with Cu-base filler metal. Journal of Materials Research and Technology 9(1): 465-477.
15. Yan Zhang, Yankun Chen, Jianping Zhou (2020) Interfacial microstructure evolution and mechanical properties of TC₄ alloy-304 stainless steel joints with different joining modes. Materials Letters.
16. Tomashchuk I, Sallamand P, Andrzejewski H, Grevey D (2011) The formation of intermetallics in dissimilar Ti₆Al₄V/copper/AISI 316 L electron beam and Nd: YAG laser joints. Intermetallics 19: 1466-1473.
17. Li HM, Sun DQ, Cai XL, Dong P,Wang WQ (2012) Laser welding of TiNi shape memory alloy and stainless-steel using Ni interlayer. Mater Des 39: 285-293.
18. Yan Zhang, Daqian Sun, Xiaoyan Gu (2019) Characterization of Laser-Welded Ti Alloy and Stainless-Steel Joint Using Cu Interlayer. Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance (10): 6092-6101.
19. Bricknell RH, Melton KN, Mercier O (1979) The structure of NiTiCu shape memory alloys. Metall Trans A 10: 693-697.
20. Yan Zhang, Yuanbo Bi, Jianping Zhou, DaQian Sun, HongMei Li (2019) Strength improvement and interface characteristic of TC₄ Ti alloy and 304 stainless steel joints based on a hybrid connection mechanism. Journal of Materials Research and Technology 9(2): 1340-1343.